Home » THE LAWYER, THE JUDGE AND SOCIAL MEDIA

THE LAWYER, THE JUDGE AND SOCIAL MEDIA

A Call for Professional Restraint

By Bilyaminu Lukman Maihanchi, Esq.
Human Rights & Public Interest Lawyer | Notary Public of Nigeria

Social media has transformed the way lawyers communicate with the public. It has also created a new temptation: the temptation to turn every legal disagreement into a public spectacle.

A lawyer is entitled to disagree with a judgment. A lawyer is entitled to criticise judicial reasoning. A lawyer is entitled to appeal a decision considered erroneous.

But there must be a line between criticising a judgment and undermining the Judiciary.

The distinction is fundamental.

When a judgment goes against a lawyer’s client, political party or personal interest, the appropriate response is not ridicule, insult or an attack on the integrity of the court. The law provides an appellate process.

The Chief Justice of Nigeria recently reminded the legal profession that there are proper channels for criticising judgments and complaining about judicial conduct, warning against turning professional disagreements into personal attacks, threats or harassment on social media.

That warning deserves serious reflection.

Politics must not change our professional identity

This is particularly important during an election season.

Lawyers are entitled to participate in politics. We can contest elections, belong to political parties and support candidates. But political involvement does not suspend our professional obligations.

A lawyer remains a lawyer even when wearing a political cap.

Our political interests may change. Our parties may change. Elections will come and go. But the dignity of the legal profession must remain.

Criticise the judgment, not the institution

There is nothing unethical about saying:

«“With respect, I disagree with the judgment. I believe the court erred in law, and we shall challenge the decision on appeal.”»

That is legal advocacy.

But when criticism descends into allegations that a judge is politically compromised, that the Judiciary is acting as an instrument of a political interest, or that a court should simply be disregarded because its decision is inconvenient, we have entered a different territory.

A lawyer should know the difference.

Seniority should produce restraint

It is particularly concerning when such language comes from experienced practitioners.

Twenty years at the Bar should produce maturity.

An LL.M. should deepen one’s appreciation of the law.

A Ph.D. in law should strengthen one’s understanding of constitutional institutions.

Professional experience should teach us that not every disagreement requires a social-media battle.

The more senior a lawyer becomes, the greater the responsibility to guide younger lawyers by example.

Recent remarks by the CJN, AGF and NBA leadership have similarly emphasised that professional distinction does not place lawyers beyond accountability and that the dignity of the profession is a collective responsibility of the Bench and Bar.

Let the appellate courts speak

Where a lawyer believes that a judgment is wrong, appeal it.

Where a judicial officer has acted improperly, use the appropriate complaint mechanism.

Where a legal proposition is wrong, answer it with law and authority.

But social media should not become a substitute for the appellate process, nor should political popularity become a substitute for professional responsibility.

The Judiciary must be open to legitimate criticism. At the same time, judges must be protected from intimidation and personal attacks so that they can decide cases according to law and conscience.

As lawyers, we must defend both principles.

We can disagree without being disrespectful.
We can criticise without undermining.
We can participate in politics without abandoning professionalism.

The question every lawyer should ask before pressing “Post” is simple:

Would I be prepared to defend these words before the appropriate professional authority?

If the answer is no, perhaps the better course is not to publish them.

Political relevance is temporary. Professional integrity is permanent.