Home » TAKUM: MURI’S COEXISTENCE PROPOSAL REOPENS DEBATE OVER TRADITIONAL AUTHORITY

TAKUM: MURI’S COEXISTENCE PROPOSAL REOPENS DEBATE OVER TRADITIONAL AUTHORITY

RIKWENSE MURI RIKWENSE MURI

Amik asks “what is the architecture?”

Luka defends hierarchy.

Dr. Wakili insists peace must be anchored in justice

By Taraba News Feature Desk

The long-running debate over the traditional institution of Takum has entered another phase following an interview granted by Dr. Rikwense Muri to SUM TV’s Issues of the Moment, in which he advanced what he described as a possible pathway for reconciling competing traditional aspirations without necessarily dividing Takum Local Government Area.

SUM TV Logo

Muri’s intervention has since generated responses from Amik Adams Aminu, Riman N Luka and Dr. Jerome T. Wakili, each examining the proposal from a different perspective.

While Muri emphasises coexistence, cultural dignity and the possibility of multiple traditional institutions operating within one Local Government Area, Aminu says he is interested in the direction but wants the “architecture” of the proposal explained.

Luka questions whether the experience of Bali can appropriately be applied to Takum and argues that Takum’s own history and hierarchical traditional structure should guide any solution.

Wakili goes further into questions of legality, customary legitimacy, consent and due process, arguing that reconciliation without justice could leave the underlying grievance unresolved.

The emerging debate therefore goes beyond the immediate question of who should occupy a traditional institution.

It touches on a much larger question:

Can Takum develop a traditional arrangement that protects the identity and dignity of its different communities without creating new jurisdictional disputes or weakening the traditional structure itself?

MURI’S SUM TV INTERVENTION

During his appearance on SUM TV’s Issues of the Moment, Muri argued that the traditional question should be separated from the issue of political and administrative boundaries.

His central proposition was that traditional authority and Local Government administration do not necessarily have to correspond to the same territorial arrangement.

In his view, a Local Government Area can remain politically and administratively intact while accommodating different traditional institutions representing different communities.

RIKWENSE MURI
RIKWENSE MURI

Muri used the example of Bali, where, according to his account, different traditional authorities coexist within the same Local Government Area.

The lesson he draws from that example is not necessarily that Takum should be divided.

Rather, he believes the experience demonstrates that the existence of more than one traditional authority within one Local Government Area is not, in itself, incompatible with administrative unity.

For Muri, this distinction is fundamental.

He says he is not advocating the partition of Takum Local Government Area, the displacement of communities or the transfer of political authority from one ethnic group to another.

Instead, he proposes a framework in which communities can retain their cultural identities and legitimate traditional institutions while continuing to belong to one politically administered Local Government Area.

THE KUTEB ASPIRATION

Muri’s position places particular emphasis on the Kuteb traditional institution.

He describes the Ukwe as the principal traditional institution of the Kuteb and argues that preserving the dignity of that institution does not necessarily require other ethnic communities in Takum to surrender their own identities.

In his formulation, the Kuteb should be able to preserve the Ukwe institution, while communities such as the Chamba, Kpanzon, Tiv, Hausa, Mbakpa, Tikari and others retain their own cultural identities and traditional institutions.

Muri’s argument is therefore based on the possibility of coexistence rather than cultural domination.

He asks whether the preservation of one people’s traditional dignity necessarily requires the cultural submission or displacement of another.

His answer is no.

The challenge, therefore, is to construct a framework in which different communities can preserve their identities while remaining part of the same political and administrative space.

TRADITIONAL AUTHORITY VERSUS GOVERNMENTAL ADMINISTRATION

A major part of Muri’s argument rests on the distinction between traditional authority and governmental administration.

A Local Government Area is an administrative structure created within the Nigerian system of government.

Traditional institutions, on the other hand, are associated with history, culture, customary practices, community identity and traditional leadership.

Muri argues that because the two institutions serve different purposes, they do not necessarily have to operate according to identical boundaries.

Under this interpretation, recognising a traditional institution would not automatically amount to creating a new Local Government Area.

The distinction is important because the word “separation” can carry different meanings.

Separation of traditional jurisdictions is not necessarily the same thing as political partition.

But that distinction is precisely where the debate begins to become more complicated.

AMINU: “I AGREE WITH THE DIRECTION, BUT I WANT TO UNDERSTAND THE ARCHITECTURE”

Amik Adams Aminu’s response to Muri is notable because he does not begin by rejecting the proposal.

Instead, he says he finds the direction interesting and conciliatory.

He nevertheless asks a fundamental question:

What exactly is the architecture behind it?

For Aminu, it is not enough to say that different traditional institutions can coexist.

The practical structure must also be explained.

If Takum is to remain one Local Government Area while different traditional jurisdictions coexist within it, where would one traditional jurisdiction end and another begin?

Would the boundaries be geographical?

Would they be determined by ethnicity?

Would a person’s traditional allegiance follow their place of residence or their ethnic identity?

These questions become particularly important because communities in Takum have historically interacted, settled alongside one another and intermarried.

Aminu therefore asks what would happen in mixed communities.

If a community contains Kuteb, Chamba, Tiv, Kpanzon or other populations, which traditional authority would exercise jurisdiction?

Would everyone living there come under the same traditional ruler?

Or would different residents answer to different traditional institutions based on their ethnic identities?

Aminu’s questions do not necessarily amount to a rejection of Muri’s proposal.

Rather, they challenge its supporters to explain how the concept would function in practice.

THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CHIEFDOMS AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT

Aminu also stresses the importance of distinguishing between traditional chiefdoms and Local Government Areas.

That distinction is central to the debate.

Creating or recognising a traditional jurisdiction does not automatically mean creating another Local Government Area.

But, at the same time, a traditional jurisdiction involves questions of authority, representation, customary leadership and potentially territorial boundaries.

Therefore, any proposal involving multiple traditional institutions would need to explain the relationship between those institutions and the existing administrative structure.

This is particularly important in a politically sensitive environment where terminology can easily be interpreted differently by different communities.

Aminu’s concern is that if the proposal is poorly explained, people could interpret traditional separation as political partition.

That, in turn, could create new fears around an already sensitive issue.

LUKA: TAKUM MUST BE UNDERSTOOD ON ITS OWN TERMS

Riman N Luka approaches the debate from a substantially different position.

For him, the central problem is the possibility of importing an arrangement from another community into Takum without sufficiently considering Takum’s own historical and cultural development.

His reference point is the Bali example.

While Muri sees Bali as evidence that multiple traditional authorities can coexist within one Local Government Area, Luka argues that different cultures have different histories and institutional arrangements.

Consequently, an arrangement that exists in Bali cannot automatically become a template for Takum.

Luka maintains that Takum historically operated within a hierarchical traditional structure in which there was a paramount traditional ruler.

His argument is that weakening or restructuring that hierarchy could have consequences for the coherence of the traditional institution.

He therefore advocates preserving a clear hierarchical traditional structure while ensuring that all constituent communities receive dignity, fairness and respect.

His concern is not that other communities should lose their identities.

Rather, he questions whether the preservation of those identities necessarily requires creating parallel paramount authorities.

THE FEAR OF FURTHER FRAGMENTATION

Underlying Luka’s position is a concern about what he regards as the danger of further fragmentation of Takum’s traditional structure.

His argument is that if every major ethnic interest receives a separate paramount traditional institution within the same traditional space, the result could be competing centres of authority.

That could create new questions:

Who has authority over a particular village?

Who handles disputes?

Who speaks for the community?

Which traditional institution should government recognise on a particular matter?

And where does the authority of one institution stop?

For Luka, these questions are not theoretical.

They go to the heart of whether a traditional institution can remain coherent.

His preferred approach is therefore to retain a clear traditional hierarchy while strengthening mechanisms for fairness, inclusion and respect for the various communities.

WAKILI: “PEACE WITHOUT JUSTICE MAY NOT LAST”

Dr Jerome T. Wakili’s response introduces perhaps the strongest emphasis on law, justice and due process.

In his rejoinder to Muri’s SUM TV interview, Wakili argues that the Takum question should not be approached exclusively as a political reconciliation exercise.

He distinguishes between a political approach, which may prioritise compromise and a “win-win” settlement, and a legal/customary approach that requires disputes to be resolved within the applicable legal and customary framework.

For Wakili, reconciliation is valuable, but reconciliation cannot substitute for justice.

His concern is that if an arrangement is regarded by an affected community as having been imposed without proper consultation, consent or due process, asking that community to accept it simply for the sake of peace may not resolve the underlying grievance.

In that sense, Wakili’s argument is that peace must be legitimate as well as peaceful.

THE QUESTION OF CONSENT

Consent is therefore central to Wakili’s analysis.

He raises questions about how changes to traditional institutions are made and whether the communities whose customary interests are directly affected have been adequately consulted.

He argues that traditional institutions cannot be treated simply as administrative appointments because they often carry deep cultural meaning.

A staff of office, in his formulation, is not necessarily sufficient evidence of broad customary acceptance.

The process through which authority is established matters.

Who was consulted?

What customary procedure was followed?

Was there agreement among the relevant traditional institutions?

Were affected communities given an opportunity to participate?

Were applicable laws followed?

These questions, according to Wakili’s argument, must be addressed if a settlement is expected to survive beyond the current generation.

THE BALI MODEL UNDER SCRUTINY

The Bali example consequently becomes a major point of disagreement.

Muri uses it to demonstrate that different traditional authorities can coexist within one Local Government Area.

Wakili and Luka caution that the existence of an arrangement elsewhere does not necessarily establish its suitability for Takum.

Wakili also raises concerns about the clarity of traditional boundaries in the Bali context, using that issue to illustrate the potential consequences of overlapping or insufficiently defined jurisdictions.

His broader argument is that a model that contains unresolved jurisdictional questions should not automatically be presented as a solution to another community’s dispute.

The disagreement therefore goes beyond Bali itself.

It is about whether traditional governance should be approached through general principles or through community-specific historical and customary arrangements.

WHAT HAPPENS IN MIXED COMMUNITIES?

Aminu’s question about mixed communities may ultimately prove to be one of the most difficult practical issues.

Takum’s social reality is not necessarily organised into completely separate ethnic settlements.

People have interacted for generations.

There are families with relationships across communities, people who have moved from one area to another, and communities whose social and economic lives are interconnected.

If traditional jurisdiction is territorial, then everyone living within that territory could potentially fall under the same traditional authority.

But if it is primarily ethnic, people living in the same geographical community could potentially owe allegiance to different traditional institutions.

Each approach presents different implications.

A territorial system could protect administrative clarity but potentially weaken ethnic-specific traditional identity.

An ethnic system could preserve cultural affiliation but create overlapping jurisdictions.

A hybrid arrangement might attempt to combine both, but would require detailed rules.

This is the “architecture” Aminu is asking Muri and other proponents of coexistence to explain.

THE QUESTION OF INTERMARRIAGE

The debate also raises the issue of intermarriage.

Wakili’s position is that marriage does not automatically erase the customary identity or jurisdictional traditions of the communities involved.

This raises an important broader question.

In modern communities where identities increasingly overlap, how should traditional institutions respond?

Can traditional authority remain entirely ethnicity-based when communities are increasingly socially integrated?

Or should residence and territory become more important?

And what happens where a person has legitimate connections to more than one community?

These questions may require more than political speeches.

They may require clear customary, legal and administrative guidelines.

MURI’S BROADER PHILOSOPHY: AVOIDING WINNER-TAKES-ALL

At the heart of Muri’s intervention is a philosophical argument about the meaning of peace.

He suggests that Takum’s traditional question has too often been framed as a contest between victory and defeat.

Who owns what?

Who lost what?

Who took what?

Whose historical account must prevail?

Muri proposes a different question:

Can the legitimate cultural aspirations of one people be accommodated without humiliating, displacing or diminishing another?

That is the basis of his coexistence argument.

His position does not claim that every historical or legal question has been resolved.

Rather, he appears to be arguing that communities should explore institutional arrangements that allow them to preserve dignity without requiring permanent confrontation.

WAKILI’S COUNTERPOINT: ACCOMMODATION IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR JUSTICE

Wakili’s response challenges that approach at its foundation.

He argues that accommodation should not become a mechanism for avoiding unresolved legal or customary questions.

In his view, tolerance does not mean abandoning legitimate claims, and peace should not require a community to accept what it considers an unlawful or procedurally defective arrangement.

His emphasis is therefore on the sequence of events:

law, consultation, consent, legitimacy and then sustainable peace.

The implication is that a settlement reached without addressing the foundation of the dispute may remain vulnerable.

THE CENTRAL QUESTION: ONE HIERARCHY OR MULTIPLE AUTHORITIES?

The debate now appears to have crystallised around two broad institutional possibilities.

One approach favours maintaining a clear paramount traditional hierarchy while ensuring that constituent communities receive representation, dignity and cultural recognition.

The other explores the possibility of multiple recognised traditional institutions operating within one Local Government Area, with clearly defined spheres of authority.

Neither proposition can simply be evaluated by rhetoric.

Each raises practical questions about jurisdiction, legitimacy, recognition and governance.

If a single paramount structure is maintained, the issue becomes how competing cultural aspirations will be accommodated within it.

If multiple institutions are recognised, the issue becomes how their jurisdictions will be defined and how overlapping claims will be prevented.

WHAT DOES PEACE ACTUALLY MEAN?

The debate also exposes different understandings of peace.

For Muri, peace is closely associated with coexistence and accommodation.

For Aminu, peace requires an arrangement sufficiently clear that communities understand who has authority over what.

For Luka, peace requires preservation of a traditional structure that he considers consistent with Takum’s history, while ensuring fairness to constituent communities.

For Wakili, peace must be anchored in justice, legality, due process and customary legitimacy.

These positions are different, but they are not necessarily mutually exclusive.

A durable framework could, in principle, require elements of all four:

– recognition of cultural dignity;
– clarity of traditional jurisdiction;
– respect for historical and customary institutions;
– consultation and consent;
– legal and administrative certainty;
– and mechanisms for resolving future disputes peacefully.

THE ROLE OF GOVERNMENT AND THE COURTS

Another critical dimension is the role of formal state institutions.

Traditional authority operates within a modern constitutional and administrative system.

Government therefore has a role in recognising traditional institutions according to applicable law and policy.

At the same time, where disputes are before the courts, political actors and commentators must be cautious about presenting contested questions as settled facts.

This is particularly important because the Takum question involves historical narratives, customary claims and institutional legitimacy that may be interpreted differently by different communities.

The current public debate should therefore complement, rather than prejudge, formal legal processes.

THE ROAD AHEAD

The latest exchange suggests that the Takum debate may benefit from moving from accusations towards structured questions.

If the coexistence model is to be examined, its proponents would need to provide greater clarity on:

Jurisdiction:
Who exercises authority and over what territory or population?

Boundaries:
Where does one traditional jurisdiction begin and another end?

Mixed communities:
How are communities with multiple ethnic populations governed?

Customary disputes:
Which institution handles disputes involving people from different traditional jurisdictions?

Recognition:
What legal and governmental processes are required for recognition or alteration of traditional institutions?

Consent:
Who must be consulted before any arrangement is implemented?

Hierarchy:
How do first-class and second-class traditional institutions relate to one another?

Future disputes:
What mechanisms prevent the new arrangement from becoming another source of conflict?

These questions are important regardless of which institutional model ultimately receives consideration.

A DEBATE THAT SHOULD NOT BECOME ANOTHER CONFLICT

There is perhaps one area where the different interventions offer an important common lesson.

The debate itself should not become another source of division.

Muri has called for a departure from the language of winner and loser.

Aminu has urged deeper interrogation of the proposed architecture.

Luka has called attention to Takum’s historical and cultural uniqueness.

Wakili has insisted on justice, due process, consultation and customary legitimacy.

Taken together, these perspectives suggest that any lasting solution will require more than deciding who occupies a traditional stool.

It will require determining how different communities understand their history, identity and relationship with traditional authority—and then finding an institutional framework capable of managing those differences peacefully.

TAKUM’S FUTURE: THE QUESTION BEYOND THE STOOL

Ultimately, the Takum question is about more than a title.

It is about identity.

It is about history.

It is about customary authority.

It is about community dignity.

It is about law.

And, perhaps most importantly, it is about the kind of social relationship the people of Takum want to leave for the next generation.

The fundamental question may therefore no longer be simply:

Who should have the paramount authority?

It may also be:

What arrangement can allow the different communities of Takum to live with dignity, preserve their identities, resolve disputes peacefully and avoid transmitting today’s grievances to tomorrow’s children?

Muri’s SUM TV intervention has reopened that conversation.

Amik Aminu has asked for the architecture.

Riman N Luka has challenged the transplantation of external models and defended the importance of Takum’s historical hierarchy.

Dr Jerome Wakili has placed justice, legality, consent and customary legitimacy at the centre of the discussion.

The debate remains unresolved.

But if it is conducted with restraint, historical honesty, respect for differing perspectives and attention to law and customary practice, it could contribute to a more serious conversation about the future of traditional authority in Takum.

The ultimate measure of any proposed solution will not simply be whether it settles today’s argument.

It will be whether it prevents tomorrow’s conflict.

And that is why the question before Takum is bigger than the stool itself.

It is the question of how different peoples can share one political space, preserve their dignity and history, and still build a common future.